THE ILIAD
Helen, the Olympian-born, dazzlingly beautiful trophy wife of Sparta's King Menelaus was melancholic in her marriage. Helen yearned for the companionship of the gorgeous young man whom she had seen only in a vision: Paris, the Prince of Troy. As luck would have it, Paris managed to "abduct" Helen and spirit her off to his homeland, where she was welcomed by his father, King Priam, despite the portents of doom from Paris' foresighted sister, Cassandra .
Helen’s beauty practically incited the Trojan War that killed untold thousands of souls. Furthermore it is the center piece of the Greek myth. Hesiod describes Helen, "...others brought in boats over the great gulf of the sea to Troy for the sake of fair-haired Helen." He also refers to these warriors as "more just and superior, the godly race of men-heroes, who are called demigods..." The exploits of the heroes of the Trojan War form the essence of the Greek stories that Greek religion was based upon for hundreds of years later.
THE ODYSSEY
The call of his oath to reclaim Helen from Troy caused the separation between Odysseus, the architect of the Trojan horse that spelled V-I-C-T-O-R-Y for the Spartans, and Penelope, his wife and Queen of Ithaca. However, as he sailed home after the war, he soon found himself fighting for his life as Poseidon, the god of the seas that harbors a bitter grudge against him, planned to wreak revenge on him at any cost. For those 20 years that his departed husband struggled to free his path towards Ithaca, where was the beautiful Penelope?
COMPARISON
A battlefield on which men heroically fight to the death, with the ground littered with bodies, that’s what the two epics of Homer were about. But underneath the gore and carnage of the men's bodies are the twisted and bound bodies of live women on their backs. The above visual is an attempt to distill the apparent role of women in general and Helen and Penelope in particular in Homer's world and the world he depicts in his poems. Rather than individual persons who control their lives and their environment, women in The Iliad and The Odyssey operate as pawns controlled by the men who control the world in which they live.
Helen was made to display her naked body in front of the leering eyes of nobles and commoners alike.
Penelope can only tolerate the rowdy mob of suitors who have overrun her palace and pillaged her land because well, custom dictated her to eventually remarry.
What made them different, if you ask me, is their attitude towards the anguish caused by the men in their life.
Helen, escaped; Penelope, endured.
Helen, escaped; Penelope, endured.
Helen left behind all sense of morality, shame, and responsible behavior as she bared heart and soul to Paris. She turned a blind eye to reason and followed her heart albeit she was aware that his husband would come after her and that thousands would lay their lives for this unworthy cause. So, what do you call the one thing that launched a thousand ships….against another? A villain, an antagonist, or the baddie, that’s what she is. Call her whatever you want, but underneath her golden Aphrodite exterior lies a woman not worthy of a crown.
The trait of endurance that marks Odysseus is mirrored in his wife Penelope, who never lost faith in her husband despite the pressure her many suitors place on her to remarry. In the 20 years of Odysseus’s absence, Penelope had done nothing but heavily uphold her honor and hope and wait patiently amidst all odds that her husband’s ship is just on the horizon, his men rowing briskly towards Ithaca. She was the epitome of what a devoted wife should be – submissive, patient and able to love unconditionally – or everything Helen as a spouse was not.
It requires no further explanation for me to conclude that in terms of character, Penelope is worth emulating; to follow the footsteps of Helen, on the other hand, can only bring tears and misfortune to a person.